Figuring enigma nepi: its cause and its consequences L'AMI DU PEUPLE
Home J. M. Keynes Austrian School of Economics and anti-objectivism argument antifilozofija as e-book Archive of MES Atheism Direct Democracy telex paper Drugs Ecology telex paper Zizek Health History Lenin Marxist Education Milton Friedman Taxation Five years L'AMI telex paper DU PEUPLE Politics Privatization telex paper Worker Rights Ron Paul Free Trade Socialism Theory Contact
"In the conditions prevailing at the end of the civil war Soviet leaders were faced with many problems that require solutions" begins telex paper chapter Levin. That nowhere in the book "Lenin's last struggle" gives the reader clear that civil war is partly the fault of the Bolsheviks (This is obviously because Levine mentions only once the Constituent Assembly without any analysis of the controversy over its dissolution. Befits you a serious historian such an oversight?). I say "partial" because the war with White guardists was inevitable. Some of these problems that require solutions, therefore, were derived telex paper from the conditions in part created by "Soviet leaders." Nepi was not the only solution. Apart from politics, the Bolsheviks served and physical destruction to cope with problems which were partly caused by themselves. Why "partially" see below. Levin asks: "As needed them to avoid confrontation with the Western powers in the period which precedes the new revolutions in Europe or Asia?" Certainly not with the destruction of the socialist telex paper opposition (these socialists become - under the Bolsheviks illegal - Opposition after the dissolution telex paper of the Constituent telex paper Assembly by State shot by the Bolsheviks, the Left Social-Revolutionists and anarchists), but with the consolidation of socialist forces, and thus, in the civil war were destroyed much earlier Apologists of the old regime.
Levin claims: "There were no ready-made solutions to problems which contained so many unknown factors." And political and economic telex paper factors telex paper are clear. Political indicated. You will discover and economic. The implications of the solutions to these problems are also clear. From a political perspective, it would be a deviation of the Bolsheviks before telex paper the socialist opposition, and probably re-establishment of the Constituent Assembly (real demand of the population), and from the economic point of view, it was the abolition of the wage system and the countryside and in the city (real request peasants and workers). telex paper Simply, it would defeat the political economy of the Bolsheviks (a party and the state as collective capitalist) launched such an unprecedented brutal way through physical and moral destruction of every opponent.
According to Levin nepi is "original and unexpected telex paper economic system." Well, the Lenin says nepi "new policy in respect of which started. And in fact it has more old than in the previous. " Levin seems not well familiar with the work of Lenin as not read systematically, which is obvious.
Levin believes that "this policy was adopted against the urgent need to recover from the stagnation that the country as a whole, but especially agriculture, fallen". telex paper But why were stagnant agriculture Levin reveals, whether from ignorance or ideological blindness (as apologist for Lenin and Bolshevism). It is our duty as Marxists discover for agriculture before the introduction nepi stagnated.
"Lenin explained that it was a measure in order to save the country from disaster, in which peasants were given the necessary concessions to encourage them to renew production and fed state; these concessions could be seen as Injection dose of capitalism. " Disaster telex paper risk in agriculture did not create none other than the Bolsheviks. Surplus crops produced by peasants, were taken by the government to support the Bolsheviks in the civil war led forces as against White guardists and against the socialist opposition. No incentive for farmers to produce surplus food, the Bolshevik government initiated telex paper forfeiture, which further obezhrabrila agricultural production. The villagers, of course, resisting harsh government measures. Peasant Establishing burning spontaneously quite country, starting in the spring of 1920 to protest food shortages and government centralization. In 1921 Kronshtadskata naval base was started an uprising against the dictatorship established by the Bolsheviks. Sailors KRONSHTAD citizens sympathized with the insurgents and formally called for an end to the Bolshevik tyranny. Insurgents platform contained 15 demands: "1. telex paper Immediate new elections for the Council. Current Tips longer represent the wishes of the workers and peasants. New elections shall be held by secret ballot and shall be preceded by free electoral propaganda. Second Freedom of speech and press for workers and peasants
Home J. M. Keynes Austrian School of Economics and anti-objectivism argument antifilozofija as e-book Archive of MES Atheism Direct Democracy telex paper Drugs Ecology telex paper Zizek Health History Lenin Marxist Education Milton Friedman Taxation Five years L'AMI telex paper DU PEUPLE Politics Privatization telex paper Worker Rights Ron Paul Free Trade Socialism Theory Contact
"In the conditions prevailing at the end of the civil war Soviet leaders were faced with many problems that require solutions" begins telex paper chapter Levin. That nowhere in the book "Lenin's last struggle" gives the reader clear that civil war is partly the fault of the Bolsheviks (This is obviously because Levine mentions only once the Constituent Assembly without any analysis of the controversy over its dissolution. Befits you a serious historian such an oversight?). I say "partial" because the war with White guardists was inevitable. Some of these problems that require solutions, therefore, were derived telex paper from the conditions in part created by "Soviet leaders." Nepi was not the only solution. Apart from politics, the Bolsheviks served and physical destruction to cope with problems which were partly caused by themselves. Why "partially" see below. Levin asks: "As needed them to avoid confrontation with the Western powers in the period which precedes the new revolutions in Europe or Asia?" Certainly not with the destruction of the socialist telex paper opposition (these socialists become - under the Bolsheviks illegal - Opposition after the dissolution telex paper of the Constituent telex paper Assembly by State shot by the Bolsheviks, the Left Social-Revolutionists and anarchists), but with the consolidation of socialist forces, and thus, in the civil war were destroyed much earlier Apologists of the old regime.
Levin claims: "There were no ready-made solutions to problems which contained so many unknown factors." And political and economic telex paper factors telex paper are clear. Political indicated. You will discover and economic. The implications of the solutions to these problems are also clear. From a political perspective, it would be a deviation of the Bolsheviks before telex paper the socialist opposition, and probably re-establishment of the Constituent Assembly (real demand of the population), and from the economic point of view, it was the abolition of the wage system and the countryside and in the city (real request peasants and workers). telex paper Simply, it would defeat the political economy of the Bolsheviks (a party and the state as collective capitalist) launched such an unprecedented brutal way through physical and moral destruction of every opponent.
According to Levin nepi is "original and unexpected telex paper economic system." Well, the Lenin says nepi "new policy in respect of which started. And in fact it has more old than in the previous. " Levin seems not well familiar with the work of Lenin as not read systematically, which is obvious.
Levin believes that "this policy was adopted against the urgent need to recover from the stagnation that the country as a whole, but especially agriculture, fallen". telex paper But why were stagnant agriculture Levin reveals, whether from ignorance or ideological blindness (as apologist for Lenin and Bolshevism). It is our duty as Marxists discover for agriculture before the introduction nepi stagnated.
"Lenin explained that it was a measure in order to save the country from disaster, in which peasants were given the necessary concessions to encourage them to renew production and fed state; these concessions could be seen as Injection dose of capitalism. " Disaster telex paper risk in agriculture did not create none other than the Bolsheviks. Surplus crops produced by peasants, were taken by the government to support the Bolsheviks in the civil war led forces as against White guardists and against the socialist opposition. No incentive for farmers to produce surplus food, the Bolshevik government initiated telex paper forfeiture, which further obezhrabrila agricultural production. The villagers, of course, resisting harsh government measures. Peasant Establishing burning spontaneously quite country, starting in the spring of 1920 to protest food shortages and government centralization. In 1921 Kronshtadskata naval base was started an uprising against the dictatorship established by the Bolsheviks. Sailors KRONSHTAD citizens sympathized with the insurgents and formally called for an end to the Bolshevik tyranny. Insurgents platform contained 15 demands: "1. telex paper Immediate new elections for the Council. Current Tips longer represent the wishes of the workers and peasants. New elections shall be held by secret ballot and shall be preceded by free electoral propaganda. Second Freedom of speech and press for workers and peasants
No comments:
Post a Comment